Quote from: DickB on May 04, 2021, 05:58:27 PMDeep discharge does also reduce battery life. batteryuniversity.com cautions against it.An occasional foray into the lower limits of what our batteries can provide isn't going to kill them because there are low voltage cutoffs in BOTH our batteries and our controllers. When our Watt display goes to 000, there is probably still somewhere around 39 or 40 volts left in the battery, which is ~3.00 to 3.08 volts per cell, which isn't particularly harmful if only done occasionally (<2.5 volts/cell is generally considered the lower limit to avoid more rapid/permanent damage to most Lithium Ion cell chemistries ).
QuoteBattery charge limits can be set by monitoring either voltage or current.Almost ALL modern Lithium Ion battery chargers are CC>CV, meaning that they maintain a constant current (like the 2 Amps for the Rad OEM charger) until a target voltage is reached (typically 54.6V for a 13 serial cell, 48 volt nominal Lithium Ebike battery pack), then they hold that voltage and let current decrease, until either shutting off completely at ~<50mA or providing a low trickle charge current as observed with Rad chargers (again, a sign of a BMS that is behind the times).
For those wanting to understand what to expect from their Rad batteries:
A fully charged battery will be able provide up to 750 Watts of power in Assist Level 5, as observed on the LCD Display.
As power is consumed, the maximum available Wattage shown on the LCD display will decrease, with only ~700, then ~600, then ~500, then ~400, then ~300, then ~200 , then ~100, then ~50, then ~25 maximum Watts available in Assist Level 5 as the Battery Capacity Bar count on the LCD display drops from 5, to 4, to 3, to 2, to 1, then 1 Flashing.
Keep going and the final single bar will start flashing. Assist Level 5 will quickly become more like 2, then 1 was on a full battery, and the Wattage readout will eventually go to 000 and you're done.
If you're pushing for maximum range using pedal power and Assist Level 1, the LCD Watts display will eventually also go to 000, but when it does, increasing to Assist Level 2 will bring back ~25 or so Watts until the the LCD Displays zeroes again, but bumping up to Assist Level 3 will bring back ~25 Watts again, and so on. This makes the end a little less surprising, if not as sudden.
Time to swap in a fresh battery for the trip home...
And FWIW, I do charge to 80% most of the time, but I have another battery that is a 17.5Ah, so at 80% it's 14Ah, which is the same as the Rad OEM battery at full charge (and it balances on the fly). I also make it a point to charge fully depleted batteries as soon as I get home, as it's best to not leave them sitting around in that state.